The Elbe Philharmonic ? A Musical Challenge

Construction of the Elbe Philharmonic is underway, with its opening planned for autumn, 2011. Hamburg?s creative artists are not alone in seeing a new landmark for their city in this spectacular concert hall.... more more

GoetheInstitute

24/08/2006

From the Feuilletons is a weekly overview of what's been happening in the German-language cultural pages and appears every Friday at 3 pm. CET.. Here a key to the German newspapers.

Die Zeit, 24.08.2006

"We need a new feminism" it says in big letters on the front page of the Life section of the weekly paper. Fifteen women, including fashion designer Gabrielle Strehle (Strenesse), comedienne Anke Engelke, writer Alexa Hennig von Lange (homepage) and judge Gerturde Lübbe-Wolf explain why. Novelist Karen Duve finds an article by newsreader Eva Herman in Cicero magazine (in which she expresses her doubts about feminism, saying it has brought more trouble than it was worth and in the light of Germany's shrinking population it would probably be better for women to stop making things complicated for themselves and get back to the stove) "enough to make you vomit bones". Duve senses a prevailing hostility in the feuilletons. "What once was goodwill has turned into something harsh and ugly, now that some of the most desirable and prestigious positions in the culture and media world are occupied by women."


"The Free Will" hits the German screens today

Matthias Glasner's provocative, disturbing film "The Free Will" (more here), which earned Jürgen Vogel a Silver Bear for best actor at this year's Berlin Film Festival, opens in German cinemas today. The feuilletons are divided on Glasner's portrayal of the loves of a sex offender.

Writing in the Süddeutsche Zeitung, Fritz Göttler would have preferred a little less instinct and a little more understanding from "The Free Will". "The loneliness of the sex offender is portrayed as a horror trip. But this portrayal lacks precision, and a clear idea of how cinematographic narrative works. The result continually slides from the analysis of a social situation into a picture of the abject side of humanity – in which Jürgen Vogel gives everything he's got. Ultimately, the film hides behind slogans and announcements in a thicket of well-meaning. And its glorification of the principle of immediacy and instinct is all too frivolous. 'Instinctively I felt: pure handicraft won't get me any further, but if we live through this, we'll be closer when we come out the other side.' 'The Free Will' doesn't lose its credibility through its excesses, but in sentences like this by its director. No American B-movie director would talk about his trade with so little respect."

Don't mention symbolism! Birgit Glombitza of die tageszeitung let's the word "pieta" slip from her lips in the course of an interview with director Matthias Glasner, who counters there is no redemption in his film, and certainly not for the rapist who slashes his wrists and dies in the lap of his weeping girlfriend. "This stupid pieta! Oddly enough no ordinary cinema-goer has mentioned it, only journalists. It always gives me the impression that journalists are bringing it up only to please themselves. And the amazing thing is that the film does not make this explicit in any way. Pieta would mean that the film steps back and makes an image. We are right in the middle of Nettie's complete inability to do anything, here is a woman who has no idea any more about what she should do. There is nothing symbolic about that, nothing aggrandised. It is all very intuitive and direct."


Berliner Zeitung, 24.08.2006


Martin Ebbing has visited the exhibition of Holocaust cartoons in Tehran, observing "the absolute normality, how completely matter of course the show is for organisers and visitors alike. No one seemed to take offence, and there's not a whit of indignation. Visitors at the 'Museum for Contemporary Palestinian Art' in the centre of the city nod approvingly in front of the drawings, each of which is supposed to represent a sort of intercontinental weapon in the clash of cultures." Ebbing quotes the exhibition director Massoud Shojai Tabatabai, who asks: "Why is it that in the West cartoonists can insult the Prophet Muhammad with impunity, but are punished when they portray the Holocaust?" One answer was given by Andre Glucksmann here at signandsight in March.


Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung, 24.08.2006

Mark Siemons has read "Chinese Beauties" The book was written by Zhang Xiaomei, publisher of a major fashion magazine and consultant to the government on all questions pertaining to the beauty industry." She explains the true hallmarks of Chinese beauty: "Cherry lips, peach blossom eyes (long and moist, with the corners slightly raised), wasp-waisted and willowy, light enough to dance like a swallow on the back of a hand, and white skin (epitomising reserve and elegance) which sometimes blushes slightly (sublimity and arousal)." Chinese find actress Zhao Wei the most beautiful of all (images here, here and here), the new supermodel Du Juan is considered alright (image here), actress Zhang Ziyi is seen as moderately cute (images here, here and here), while no one at all in China can understand why model Lu Yan is so successful in the West (image here).


Der Tagesspiegel, 24.08.2006

Berliner lawyer and patron Peter Raue makes a sharply polemic case against the return of Ernst Ludwig Kirchner's painting "Berliner Straßenszene" (1913) to the heirs of a Jewish family who in 1938 sold the painting to Germany from their exile in Switzerland. "No one knows what considerations prompted Berlin cultural Senator Thomas Flierl to extend the restitution demands to the case of a voluntary return of a painting to Germany and to give up the painting unconditionally: without public discussion, without calling in an informed commission, without expert certification." In a counter-article Senator Flierl argues there are no doubts that the family was racially persecuted and forced to sell the painting for money: "In 1936 the office of the Nazi district financial advisor enquired whether the employees, board members, supervisory board members or shareholders of the shoe factory were Jewish. The answer must have been affirmative. In 1937 the Hess family lost their shareholdings because of Nazi rule."

Get the signandsight newsletter for regular updates on feature articles.
signandsight.com - let's talk european.

 
More articles

From the Feuilletons

Saturday 4 - Friday 10 October

Reactions to JMG Le Clezio's Nobel Prize are at best lukewarm. An anonymous banker discusses the personal advantages of his job. Ralf Dahrendorf refuses to bitch about the Americans. The point is not whether women in Turkey should wear the headscarf, says Necla Kelek, but where they can go without it. La Traviata has been transformed on Platform 9 in Zurich's central station. And now for a blasphemous question: Was Beuys an "eternal Hitler youth"?
read more

From the Feuilletons

Thursday 2 October, 2008

The SZ celebrates a scattering of doppelgängers in a new production of Kafka's "Trial". It also ogles a philosophical diable de l'amour on Arte. In die Welt, Peter Weibel debunks the cult of the artist. The Berliner Zeitung marvels at the riches of Omsk. The NZZ fumes at the arrogance of Horace Engdahl and revisits the cleavage of Madame de Stael.
read more

From the Feuilletons

Friday 26 September 2008

Actor Moritz Bleibtreu tells how playing RAF terrorist Andreas Baader like he was could only result in comedy. Simon Rattle, Daniel Harding and Michael Boder have conducted Karlheinz Stockhausen's "Groups for Three Orchestras" like a flight in a helicopter. Bulgarian author Georgi Gospodinov explains why Berlin's urinals are different from Bulgaria's. And Uwe Tellkamp's thousand page novel "Der Turm" about a small GDR elite has hit reviewers like a bombshell.
read more

From the Feuilletons

Friday 19 September, 2008

The FR castigates the Germans for being so nuts about Obama when they've never elected so much as a Turkish mayor. Author and entrepeneur, Ernst-Wilhelm Händler, declares that it's not capitalism that has failed but the state. Andrzej Stasiuk spent his holidays in the Russian steppes where unlimited space felt penal. The NZZ sings a swan song for German theatre's Utopian dreams and the SZ bids farewell to the man who put the fun back into New Music.
read more

From the Feuilletons

Friday 12 September, 2008

Ukrainian author Oksana Zabuzhko remembers the mass grave in the forest of Bykivnya, where the bodies are inscribed with "the Russian signature". Marcia Pally lists a string of dirty wars waged by the Democrats. The SZ praises "Gomorrah" the Mafia film with no Godfatherly glamour. Georgian writer Dato Barbakadze tells Russian intellectuals to raise their voices in protest. And the Tagesspiegel celebrates the very un-McKinseyan ethos of Cern.
read more

From the Feuilletons

Friday 5 September, 2008

Jungle World investigates academic anti-Semitism and Jewish self-hatred with Theodor Lessing. It also looks at Gaussian distribution as an instrument of suppression. Christoph Schlingensief talks about his stay in the first station of hell. The feuilletons are relieved to finally close the chapter on the Bayreuth war of succession. And Andreas Dresen's film "Cloud 9" ushers in the grey phase of the sexual revolution.
read more

From the Feuilletons

Saturday 23 - Friday 29 August, 2008

Sitting in Moscow traffic, Sonja Margolina learns a tough lesson about life in Russian civil society. The Tagesspiegel dismisses the second volume of Günter Grass's autobiography, "The Box", as an orgy of vagueness. Christoph Schlingensief remembers how Wolfgang Wagner stole his urinal. And Die Zeit fears for the youth of today, who have had the protest scared out of them.
read more

From the Feuilletons

Saturday 16 - Friday 22 August, 2008

Did Carl Philipp Emmanuel hide the end of the 'Art of Fugue'? Organist Ton Koopman casts aspersions on Bach's son. Michel Houellebecq explains why the problem is genital. Diedrich Diederichsen remembers meeting a certain New York waitress back in '82. Ukrainian writer Yuri Andrukhovych explains why he's on Georgia's side. Osssetian literature academic Shanna Chochiyeva explains why she thinks the Georgians are Nazis. And Czech playright Pavel Kohout says what the Russians need is another revolution.
read more

From the Feuilletons

Friday 9-15 August, 2008

Georgian author Devi Dumbadze criticises the powerless nationalism of his compatriots. Andre Glucksman and Bernard-Henri Levy diagnose Europe in a coma. A new book by Patrick Buisson describes the erotic confusion that gripped Vichy France. Syrian philospher Sadik Jalal al-Azm points to a third way for Islam. The SZ takes a magical history tour of YouTube piano recitals. And old Austrian men in lederhosen take to the streets in protest against Kippenberger's crucified frog.
read more

From the Feuilletons

Saturday 26 July - Friday 1 August, 2008

This year's 'Parsifal' in Bayreuth is a romp through German history. Twenty years after the fall of the Wall, Ingo Schulze says the West has made less than minimal progress. A group of intellectuals take up Pascal Bruckner's appeal to "Boycott Durban 2". Anselm Kiefer reveals all about his Virgin Mary visitation. Necla Kelek is deeply suspicious of Tariq Ramadan's campaign against forced marriage. And Carlos Fraenkel is wowed by the hermeneutic flexibility of Indonesian Muslims.
read more

From the Feuilletons

Saturday 19 - Friday 25 July, 2008

Karadzic's successful hiding methods prompt the SZ to draw up a set of rules for war criminals living underground: rise early and travel to work by bus or train. The Bosnian writer Dzevad Karahasan remembers the thousands of lesser war criminals who are still living in impunity. Theatre director Ariane Mnouchkin has produced a number of short protest films against the Olympic Games in Bejing. And Berlin is still recovering from a breathless weekend of Obamarama.
read more

From the Feuilletons

Saturday 12 - Friday 18 July, 2008

Romanian-German writer Herta Müller protests against the participation of former Securitate informants in the Berlin Summer Academy. Richard Wagner seconds her objections. South African writer Andre Brink explains why he remains loyal to his homeland. Spanish poet Marcos Ana remembers how he smuggled his first poem out of prison in a tube of toothpaste. Sociologist Gerhard Schulze examines the very real fears about nursing homes. And Algerian author Boualem Sansal egotistically pins his hopes on the democratising forces of the Mediterranean Union.
read more

From the Feuilletons

Saturday 4 - Friday 11 July, 2008

German President Horst Köhler managed to be out of the room, when the Tibet question was raised. Author and Iranian regime critic Said explains why he was prevented from giving a reading in Berlin together with an Israeli colleague. The Russian cultural minister announces that the state will be commissioning major feature films to further the cause of patriotism. Mongolian shaman and author Galsan Tschinag reports on post-election protests in Ulan Bator. And Die Zeit portrays Chinese environmental activist Wu Lihong, who is sitting out a prison sentence.
read more

From the Feuilletons

Saturday 28 June - Friday 4th July

Moscow curator Andrei Erofeyev has lost his job because of the negative effects of art on the mind. The SZ welcomes Fethullah Gülen as the world's top public intellectual and merrily waves goodbye to the Enlightenment in the process. Die Welt reads a black book of the French Revolution. Die Presse explains what the United Nations Human Rights Council understands by "abuse of freedom of expression". On Kafka's 125th birthday, the feuilletons heap praise on the second volume of Reiner Stach's biography. And Jonathan Franzen explains what he loves about Berlin: it's a shadow of its former self.
read more

From the Feuilletons

Saturday 21 - Friday 27 June, 2008

Olivier Roy locates the roots of Islamic radicalisation in the West not the Koran. Slavenka Drakulic comments on the UN's decision to classify rape as a war crime. Peter Handke's love of Serbia is obscene says Jonathan Littell. Günther Verheugen and Jürgen Habermas argue about the Irish "no". Habermas meets Tariq Ramadan in Schloss Elmau. Writer and translator Georges-Arthur Goldschmidt slams the Parisian "Pleiade" publishers for including Ernst Jünger in their library of classics but not Thomas Mann.
read more